Argue for or against incarceration for nonviolent drug offenders

Inas prisons across the state were being forced to release inmates to comply with a court order upheld by the Supreme Court, more than 4, Californians were incarcerated for mere possession of a controlled substance. Because of the criminalized culture surrounding drug addiction, police are generally unsympathetic.

Favorable Effects of Imprisoning Drug Offenders

The truth is, they rack up tons of money and gain more power with every new measure to "clean up the streets and keep people from wrecking their lives. And everyone advancing this argument should know that to be the case: Thankfully we have the power to change mistakes our elected leaders have made.

Drug Policy

The person you see on the park bench with collapsed veins does not need a police officer or a judge or a prison guard. They could have committed any of the following crimes and still be classified "nonviolent": Please use reason and be philosophically consistent.

So who do these harsh drug laws benefit? And other countries who ban drugs only exacerbate the problem they "wish to address. InSamuel was charged with petty theft in Los Angeles. The authors stress that their figures are speculative and may not include other relevant costs and benefits.

The purity and potency is always unknown, making the likelihood of accidental poisoning or overdose much higher. The imprisonment of over one hundred thousand offenders has, moreover, had scant impact on the use or availability of drugs.

They also do not explore other, potentially more effective ways of reducing drug usage rather than incarceration. And it will get very messy.

The Fallacy of the Nonviolent Offender

The result is actually increasing crime and an ever growing abuse rate. He is now a nonviolent offender. Police readily acknowledge that for every low-level drug seller taken off the streets, another person quickly fills his or her place.

Moreover, unlike the determinate sentencing laws that got us into this mess in the first place, the proposition takes into account individual circumstances so that the sentence is appropriate to the crime and individual.

Stephen Downing is a retired LAPD deputy chief of police and a current board member of Law Enforcement Against Prohibition, a group of law enforcement officials opposed to the war on drugs.

Other weights are aggregate, including any mixture containing drug. Prison is a resource that should be used sparingly and only to the extent necessary to protect society from dangerous criminals.

A-I sentences are not restricted to major traffickers and violent king-pins. They benefit no one.

Nonviolent Drug Offenders Should Not Be Taking Up Prison Beds

Consider these two guys who were classified as "nonviolent" offenders by the legal system. However, despite this reduction in time served, other crimes did not increase more than a few percent.

This drives up the murder rate and violence in general as violence is the only way to resolve conflict "safely" in a black market. Prison was a place for bad guys. The reduction in cocaine use begins to address the long-standing question of whether the enormous costs related to tougher punishment for drug offenses yield similarly large benefits to society.

That argument is dangerous to you and the people you serve. This jump in price implies that cocaine consumption fell, perhaps as much as 20 percent.

But after months or years in custody, they become socialized to prison norms, where aggression is an asset and violence commonplace. When you begin to see the drug trade as a market which it is things become much more clear.

In the Bureau of Justice Statistics studied nonviolent offenders exiting state prisons. A minor violation any time can lead to a return to prison for the remainder of the sentence. Patrick Tracy Burris-This lovely dude recently killed five people in a serial shooting spree in Gaffney, S.

Meanwhile, our drug treatment and prevention services remain woefully underfunded. Burris had a rap sheet reportedly 25 pages long, but no convictions for "violent" offenses. He was shot and killed by Gastonia, N. Despite this enormous increase, there has been no systematic, empirical analysis until now of the implications of the new, tougher drug laws for public safety, drug markets, and public policy.

DCJS provided information on offenders sentenced to prison in So, as Michelle Alexander argued, drug prosecution is a big part of the mass incarceration story. To be clear, rolling back the war on drugs would not, as Pfaff and Urban Institute scholars.

Sep 17,  · If you listen to prison reform advocates in this country, you'll hear that our state pens are full of nonviolent drug users who got smacked down by "The Man" because they were huffing up some stems and seeds in a bong.

Mar 04,  · In light of this, experts on America’s prison system are beginning to sound an alarm: If reform-minded politicians continue to limit the prison-reduction discussion to nonviolent offenders and. Prison was a place for bad guys. As the drug war has escalated, so too have the number and length of sentences of nonviolent prisoners jailed for felony drug possession.

Favorable Effects of Imprisoning Drug Offenders "Annual expenditures of approximately $10 billion on drug incarceration almost pay for themselves through reductions in health care costs and lost productivity attributable to illegal drug use, even ignoring any crime reductions associated with such incarceration.".

At 24 years old, Kemba Smith was sentenced to years in prison for conspiracy to participate in her boyfriend's drug activities, a non-violent, first-time offense. For years, her parents galvanized a tireless movement seeking clemency for their daughter.

Argue for or against incarceration for nonviolent drug offenders
Rated 5/5 based on 100 review